Royal Commission | ASIC | |
---|---|---|
When can coercive investigatory powers be utilised? |
As part of a Royal Commission to the extent the information sought is directly relevant to the investigation as outlined in the Terms of Reference |
As part of an investigation. ASIC must have a reason to suspect a contravention has occurred. However, ASIC can be directed by the Minister to commence an investigation in the public interest |
Coercive powers |
Power to summon a person to give evidence on oath and/or produce documents, subject to exceptions where a person has been charged with an offence (s6A(3)) or proceedings in response to a penalty have commenced (s6A(4)) Power to apply for search warrants (s4) |
Coercive powers to require appearance of a witness for examination on oath (s19) inspect documents without warrant (s29), require production of documents (ss30-34) including where evidence may be self-incriminating (s 68) Power to apply for search warrants (s35) |
Offence for resisting requests |
Criminal offences for failing to give evidence, providing false or misleading evidence, destroying documents etc (ss 3,6,6H, 6O) |
Criminal offences for failing to produce (or concealing) documents, to attend examination or answer questions, and for giving false information, or obstructing investigation etc (ss63-67) |
Admissibility |
Statements made by a witness and documents produced by a person under compulsion are not admissible against them in any civil or criminal proceedings (s6DD) |
Statements made of documents produced by a witness are not admissible against them in any civil penalty or criminal proceedings, where person claims before making the statement that it might be self-incriminating (s68) |
Prosecution powers |
A Royal Commission has no power to prosecute misconduct but may refer matters to other investigatory bodies (s6P) |
ASIC has the power to initiate civil and criminal proceedings, and pursue prison terms, court orders and fines |
*legislative references are to the Royal Commission Act and to the ASIC Act